A response to Jumbo Jumbo's call to "Infi and Gang" to change the topic

Friday, February 23, 2007
A response to Jumbo Jumbo's call to "Infi and Gang" to change the topic
Dear Jumbo Jumbo, I understand your point of view. The peacemaker is the most noble of men.

In this particular case, Infidel has only been questioning. Hindus are more philosophers than academicians and are more comfortable with reconciliation of opposing points of view. However, philosophers tend to gloss over matters and a reality check is often called for. Infidel questioned the circumstances Mohammad’s marriage to Ayesha, wondering whether it squares up with the claim of Mohammad being the exemplar of mankind. He also analysed the claims of Quran on conception, pointing out similarities with Greek works on the subject and a mismatch with modern day scientific opinion. He touched on many other subjects seeking an honest discussion with Muslims. His stand, based on ground covered so far, is that the Quran is not the work of Allah but Mohammad.

If Infidel has been going around with a microphone in the public posing his questions, you would be right in saying that thereby a breach of peace would occur. But in the medium of the internet on a blog format, the discussion is restricted to those who wish to enter into it. Therefore the peacemaker has no role as no peace is breached. What is occurring is only the exercise of the individual’s freedom of expression, be it questioning or justifying.

As they say, it is not what you do that is often the issue, but when, where and how you do it. I think NDTV blogsphere is a mature enough forum to stand all sorts of questioning and also a forum where only those interested participate, unlike a public-microphone affair where often views are broadcast uncalled for.
6:17:37 AM
Posted By Venu Gopal Comments (0) Uncategorized

Infidel Friday, February 23, 2007 8:56:46 AM
Dear Venu, YOu write very well. I couldn't do better than that. Thanks brother.

Infidel Friday, February 23, 2007 10:36:29 PM
Thanks ajmal, for accepting the truth that MO was a pedophile. I quote your comment here as:"I AGREE THAT NAOOZU BILLAH HE WAS PAEDOPHIL" ajmal.rashid Friday, February 23, 2007 9:46:55 AM You got it right ajmal, now you are very close to the whole truth. Congrats.

jj Saturday, February 24, 2007 1:56:30 AM
i am neither a peace maker nor a war monger. i was just trying to prevent things from getting cancerous and cantenkerous

infidel Saturday, February 24, 2007 7:39:57 AM
Dear brother JJ,What can be a bigger cancer than islam and its zombies. You can see these bigots following their cult truly all over the world by blowing up themselves and hundreds of thousands of innocents with them.There is no term as MODERATE MUSLIMS that is a taqiyya to fool people. The only aim is to spread islam throughout the world or kill infidels to make ummah bigger.

K.Venugopal Sunday, February 25, 2007 4:08:32 PM
Infidel, as usual, has hit the nail right on the head.

Friday, February 23, 2007
infi and gang ---- pl change your topic
infi and others
ever since you ppl started your islam bashing, ndtv forum has become over crowded and saturated with your stuff.
this is totally sick and unnecessary. the common man is more concerned about his next meal than about religion.
no person has the right to comment on another person's faith. it is the most childish and immature thing to do. differences of opinion will always there.
i have differences with my brothers and friends almost everyday. thats doesnt make us enemies. one doesnt become a hindu or a muslim just by being born to hindu or muslim parents.
it is only when you sincerely practise your religion that you become a real devotee of god. a truly religious person will never have even the slightest trace of hatred in his heart.
by spewing more and more venom in this forum what exactly are you trying to achieve ?
the same question to all muslim friends who write about ram and krishna.
long ago i used to do this kind of blogging. but my conscience revolts against it and here is an earnest appeal to all of you to stop this.
this is definitely not the way to move forward. we are all sons of the same soil and our destinies are inevitably interwined. if we were to keep abusing each other, what hope do we have of a good future.
violece begets violence, hatred begets hatred. it is the innocents who get caught in this vicious cycle.
infi --- just let go. remeber the lord's promise
yadha yadha hi dharmasya glanihi bhavathi bharatha
abhyukthaanam adharmasya thadhaathmaanam srujaamyaham
if dharma needs to be protected. the lord himself has a mechanism to do it.
dont worry. just forget and forgive. reconcile to the past.
it is only the truly strong and brave who have the courage to forget and forgive.
so just let go of prophet mohammed and islam. that will do you a world of good.
cheers
jumbo
1:19:46 AM
Posted By jumbo jumbo Comments (3) Musings
Comments
perfektm Friday, February 23, 2007 1:37:50 AM
lets change it Jumbo..what do you think of this ?cultureforall.blogspot.com/2007/02/from-ashes-of-burned-train.html--PM
amardeep Friday, February 23, 2007 2:23:58 AM
ndia.jj you patience has run out but not muslims to kill indians. your patience has run out and muslims will celebrate. how long will we have our patience and look at what have muslims done in india.i will comment and will continue to bash filthy muslims till the blood is red.do you think muslims will ever ever stop their filthy activities.
jj Friday, February 23, 2007 2:51:56 AM
amardeep. this is not the way to go about. i will trust a good human being. as a hindu i am not going to trust a human being just because he is a hindu and i am not going to distrust a person just because he is a muslim